Abstract
In 1998, Gigerenzer et al. studied how heterosexual men with low-risk behavior were counseled about the accuracy of HIV test results. Most professional counselors conveyed the illusions that false positives do not occur and that a positive HIV test result means that the client is certainly infected. To help improve counseling quality, the authors provided feedback to all counseling centers in Germany. Sixteen years later we assessed whether HIV counseling in Germany has improved by replicating the original study with an expanded sample of 32 randomly selected counseling centers across the country. Since the original research, the positive predictive value (PPV) of HIV testing for a low-risk client has improved from about 50% to 96%. Hence, among every 26 low-risk clients who test positive, we can expect that one is actually not infected. Whereas test performance has improved over the last 16 years, counseling has not. About half of professional counselors communicated the illusion of certainty for sensitivity (15 of 30), specificity (16 of 30), and the PPV (18 of 30). Only one of the 30 counselors could correctly state the PPV. In what follows, we explain how to improve counselors' and clients' understanding of the PPV by representing the information in terms of natural frequencies rather than conditional probabilities. Doing so has been shown to improve the quality of counseling in different medical settings and may enhance future HIV counseling as well.
Keywords: HIV/AIDS, HIV counseling, HIV testing, natural frequencies, risk communication, risk literacy, numeracy, transparent information.
Current HIV Research
Title:What Counselors Tell Low-Risk Clients About HIV Test Performance
Volume: 13 Issue: 5
Author(s): Roman Prinz, Markus A. Feufel, Gerd Gigerenzer and Odette Wegwarth
Affiliation:
Keywords: HIV/AIDS, HIV counseling, HIV testing, natural frequencies, risk communication, risk literacy, numeracy, transparent information.
Abstract: In 1998, Gigerenzer et al. studied how heterosexual men with low-risk behavior were counseled about the accuracy of HIV test results. Most professional counselors conveyed the illusions that false positives do not occur and that a positive HIV test result means that the client is certainly infected. To help improve counseling quality, the authors provided feedback to all counseling centers in Germany. Sixteen years later we assessed whether HIV counseling in Germany has improved by replicating the original study with an expanded sample of 32 randomly selected counseling centers across the country. Since the original research, the positive predictive value (PPV) of HIV testing for a low-risk client has improved from about 50% to 96%. Hence, among every 26 low-risk clients who test positive, we can expect that one is actually not infected. Whereas test performance has improved over the last 16 years, counseling has not. About half of professional counselors communicated the illusion of certainty for sensitivity (15 of 30), specificity (16 of 30), and the PPV (18 of 30). Only one of the 30 counselors could correctly state the PPV. In what follows, we explain how to improve counselors' and clients' understanding of the PPV by representing the information in terms of natural frequencies rather than conditional probabilities. Doing so has been shown to improve the quality of counseling in different medical settings and may enhance future HIV counseling as well.
Export Options
About this article
Cite this article as:
Prinz Roman, Feufel A. Markus, Gigerenzer Gerd and Wegwarth Odette, What Counselors Tell Low-Risk Clients About HIV Test Performance, Current HIV Research 2015; 13 (5) . https://dx.doi.org/10.2174/1570162X13666150511125200
DOI https://dx.doi.org/10.2174/1570162X13666150511125200 |
Print ISSN 1570-162X |
Publisher Name Bentham Science Publisher |
Online ISSN 1873-4251 |
Call for Papers in Thematic Issues
HIV vaccine development
The development of a safe and effective vaccine that impedes HIV-1 transmission and/or limits the severity of infection remains a public health priority. The HIV-1/AIDS pandemic continues to have a disproportionate impact on vulnerable and under-served communities in the USA and globally. In the USA, minority communities that have relatively ...read more
Lymphomas in people living with HIV (PLWH)
In the era of combined antiretroviral therapy (cART), the incidence of lymphoma among people living with HIV (PLWH) surpassed Kaposi's sarcoma in 2011, becoming the most common AIDS-defining malignancy. The annual incidence rate ranges approximately from 100 to 300 per 100,000 individuals with HIV infection as the population denominator, which ...read more
- Author Guidelines
- Graphical Abstracts
- Fabricating and Stating False Information
- Research Misconduct
- Post Publication Discussions and Corrections
- Publishing Ethics and Rectitude
- Increase Visibility of Your Article
- Archiving Policies
- Peer Review Workflow
- Order Your Article Before Print
- Promote Your Article
- Manuscript Transfer Facility
- Editorial Policies
- Allegations from Whistleblowers
Related Articles
-
Studies on the Pathophysiology and Genetic Basis of Migraine
Current Genomics Scorpion Extracts Inhibit Tumor Growth in Esophageal Cancer and Lung Adenocarcinoma
Current Signal Transduction Therapy The Ca2+-Activated K+ Channel of Intermediate Conductance:A Molecular Target for Novel Treatments?
Current Drug Targets The Extent of Hydroxymethylfurfural Formation in Honey by Heating Temperature and Duration
Letters in Organic Chemistry MDMA Administration and Heat Shock Proteins Response: Foreseeing a Molecular Link
Current Pharmaceutical Biotechnology Association of Metronidazole with Cancer: A Potential Risk Factor or Inconsistent Deductions?
Current Drug Metabolism DNA Microarrays - An Armory for Combating Infectious Diseases in the New Century
Infectious Disorders - Drug Targets Polyphenols: A Potential New Strategy for the Prevention and Treatment of Anxiety and Depression
Current Nutrition & Food Science Philosophical Issues in the Prodromal Phase of Psychosis
Current Pharmaceutical Design Recent Progress in Chemosensors Using Aldehyde-bearing Fluorophores for the Detection of Specific Analytes and their Bioimaging
Current Medicinal Chemistry Advances in Systemic Therapy for Gastroenteropancreatic Neuroendocrine Malignancies
Current Clinical Pharmacology An Evidence-Based Systematic Review of Stevia by the Natural Standard Research Collaboration
Cardiovascular & Hematological Agents in Medicinal Chemistry Adenocarcinoma of the Appendix in Elderly: Diagnostic Dilemma
New Emirates Medical Journal Disintegrin Tablysin-15 Suppresses Cancer Hallmarks in Melanoma Cells by Blocking FAK/Akt/ERK and NF-κB Signaling
Current Cancer Drug Targets A Comprehensive Review on Pharmacognostical Investigation and Pharmacology of Typhonium trilobatum
The Natural Products Journal The Frequency of Thrombotic Events Among Adults Given Antifibrinolytic Drugs for Spontaneous Bleeding: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies and Randomized Trials
Current Drug Safety Alkyl Caffeates as Anti-Helicobacter Pylori and Scavenger of Oxidants Produced by Neutrophils
Medicinal Chemistry Lipid-Lowering Therapy in HIV-Infected Patients: Relationship with Antiretroviral Agents and Impact of Substance-Related Disorders
Current Vascular Pharmacology Humanized Cobra Venom Factor: Experimental Therapeutics for Targeted Complement Activation and Complement Depletion
Current Pharmaceutical Design Statistics of Catalytic Domain Sequences in Protein Kinases Vs Non-Kinases
Protein & Peptide Letters